Fragmentation and Plinian eruption of crystallizing basaltic magma

Basalt is the most ubiquitous magma on Earth, erupting typically at intensities ranging from quiescently effusive to mildly explosive. The discovery of highly explosive Plinian eruptions of basaltic magma has therefore spurred debate about their cause. Silicic eruptions of similar style are a consequence of brittle fragmentation, as magma deformation becomes progressively more viscoelastic. Magma eventually crosses the glass transition and fragments due to a positive feedback between water exsolution, viscosity and decompression rate. In contrast to silicic eruptions, the viscosity of basaltic magmas is thought to be too low to reach conditions for brittle fragmentation. Pyroclasts from several basaltic Plinian eruptions, however, contain abundant micron-size crystals that can increase magma viscosity substantially. We therefore hypothesize that magma crystallization led to brittle fragmentation during these eruptions. Using combined oscillatory and extensional rheometry of concentrated particle-liquid suspensions that are dynamically similar to microcrystalline basaltic magma, we show that high volume fractions of particles and extension rates of about 1 s⁻¹ or greater result in viscoelastic deformation and brittle fracture. We further show that for experimentally observed crystallization rate, basaltic magma can reach the empirical failure conditions when erupting at high discharge rates.